Lea Michele in Oscar de la Renta – A.
I absolutely love this dress. Perfect color and perfect style. I love sweetheart necklines on Lea, and this is no different. I know a lot of people who would prefer that she wore her hair up more often, but I think the hair-down look works in this situation. I am usually not a fan of ruffles on pretty much about anything, but I think it’s done in a classy way this time around.

Elisabeth Moss in Donna Karan — B+.
I think this dress works wonderfully on Elisabeth. I think I would’ve liked to see the same dress in a different color, such as emerald green or navy blue, to better compliment her fair skin-tone and reddish-brown hair. Other than that, I love the simplicity of the accessories and hair, and I also love the shoulder.

Kim Kardashian in Marchesa — C+.
Just so you know, I am a huge fan of Kim Kardashian [and the Kardashian family in general], but I think this was a miss for Kim. I think the dress fits her perfectly, but I would’ve liked to have seen her in a dress without an elaborate neckline. Kim is so beautiful, so anything on her neck seems to overwhelm and distract from her face. If I were to “alter” this dress, I’d make is a sweetheart neckline and in navy blue.

Tina Fey in Oscar de la Renta — C-.
I have never understood the whole “gowns with sleeves” thing, and this is no exception. I think the dress fits Tina great, but it’s a bit too busy for my liking.

Sofia Vergara in Carolina Herrera — A.
Good gosh, I love this dress so much. When she first walked out on stage last night, I gasped. So beautiful. I absolutely love this color on Sofia, and it shows off her curves, which is great. Her hair and accessories are perfect as well.

Claire Danes in Armani Prive — A.
Does Claire ever do any wrong? I don’t think so. This dress is so beautiful and she rocks it! I like that she opted to so without bracelets/necklaces/rings, because the dress is such a statement already it doesn’t need anything else.

Nina Dobrev in Zuhair Murad — A.
Love, love, love. I think I am slowly becoming a fan of one-shoulder gowns finally. This looks absolutely fantastic on her, and it isn’t overwhelmed by accessories. Bravo, Nina, bravo.

Kate Gosselin in Carmen Marc Valvo — D.
Oh Kate, I love you and your kids, but this is all wrong. I hesitate to the use the word “matronly”, but it definitely isn’t doing anything for her. I am kind of liking the top part of the dress, but the rest of it bores me.

Jane Lynch in Ali Rahimi — A.
The ladies of Glee definitely outdid themselves last night. I think Jane looks absolutely stunning in this style/color. Again, I like how simple the accessories are. It’s refreshing to see Jane out of the Cheerios track suit!

Cheryl Hines in Zac Posen — A.
Love, love, love, love, love! Again, love the one-shoulder! I am obsessing over the criss-cross/layering going on, and I think it fits Cheryl perfectly.

Jewel in Zuhair Murad — B.
This look has been getting some poor reviews, but I think it’s absolutely stunning. Because she wasn’t nominated/presenting/etc…, I think anything else would’ve been too over-the-top.

Angela Kinsey in Romona Keveza — A.
I am currently obsessed with lace, so this is perfect!  I think Angela’s hair is fantastic, and the dress is the perfect fit! Of course, I love the lace detail as well.

Jenna Fischer in Versace — A.
Fan-freaking-tastic. She looks absolutely precious. I like the lack of accessories and her hair is sheer perfection. I love the color and embellishments of the dress as well. This was made for her, definitely.

Emily Deschanel in Max Azria Atelier — A.
I debated with myself for quite some time on this look, and I ended up loving it. The purple looks wonderful against Emily’s fair skin, and I love the depth, and the one-shoulder! I could live without the bangs, but oh well.

Jayma Mays in Burberry Prorsum — A.
I think this is my favorite look of the night. The color of the dress is perfect for Jayma’s skin tone and hair color, and the gold-ness of the jewelry works wonderfully with the overall look.

Jenna Ushkowitz in Kevin Hall — B+.
Overall, I am a fan. I wish she would have worn her hair up, as to not distract from the top of the dress, but it’s not a deal-breaker. I want a closer look at those shoes, they look fantastic!

Heather Morris in Ina Soltani — B.
I am still debating whether or not I like the black belt with this dress. Overall, I love the dress and it suits Heather perfectly.

Amber Riley in Melissa Masse — B.
The only thing I do not like about the dress is the opening in the top. I would have liked to see it either closed, a strapless dress, or a dress with wide-er straps with rested on the edge of the shoulders. I think there is too much “sparkle” going on between the accessories, but it’s not a deal-breaker.